publication date: Sep 17, 2007
|
author/source: Sian Minett
I was
eager to read this book:
Ian Durston and I are both
managers with
three children. We have much
in common so I was
confident that we were
going to get along just
fine.
On the
positive side, the book is
easy to read and the
chapters are broken down into
bite-sized sections – leadership, motivation, performance etc – so you can
dip into it with ease as your
limited time
permits.
Durston
begins with the
hardly earth- shattering
assertion that parenthood and
management are extremely
similar processes as they both
involve people, so therefore you can use the
same techniques in both
spheres. If only it were that
simple!
Everything I need to know about being a manager... is largely a
collection of
anecdotes from his
experiences as a
father and as a
manager, and there is
much to
empathise with. However, many of the
connections between
management and
parenthood are either
tenuous or blindingly
obvious. For example, Durston
notes that
effective managers and parents both
require well-honed
leadership skills, citing – in the case of the latter – that
universal dilemma of
getting your child to
bed promptly so you can
enjoy dinner with friends.
Durston
presents some
useful insights (for both parents and managers) but for much of the book he
offers no
revelatory advice, but instead
repeatedly reiterates that many
issues in both spheres are “
a matter of judgement”. He also
skates over some
critical areas, such as
assertiveness.
Durston’s view is that once you
understand that everyone has a
right to his or her ow
n opinion, then being
assertive is easy. I am
sure that many
managers (particularly
women) would wish it were that
straightforward!
He also
skims over the issue of
intra-team conflict (something that is a
perennial problem in both the
work and
domestic arena!) by merely saying that when
two guys on his team
couldn’t get over their
differences “it drove him crazy”.
Elsewhere in the book he goes into
unnecessary detail, for example in the section on
communication he presents a long list of ways of
disseminating information.
It was
difficult to see what
original contribution the book really had to
offer: if you want a
parenting book you might be better off with
Biddulph (whom Durston
quotes regularly at
length) and there is tons of
literature on
business psychology; management
theory and practice if that is what you are
looking for. The book is
exactly what Durston set out
to avoid: “rambling nonsense of no use to anybody”.
I had
hoped to find the book
inspirational, but rather was
left feeling quite
inadequate compared to
Durston, who presents himself as
not only an
accomplished manager in a
high-powered jet-set job,
but also as a
great father who spends plenty of
quality time with his three
young children as well as doing the
decorating, reading the Sunday
papers and
writing a book.
Personally, I’d be more
interested in reading about how he
manages to
achieve all that!
Everything I need to know about being a manager, I learned from my kids by Ian Durston is published by
Piatkus Books Ltd. To order a
copy from
Amazon please click the
link below:
Everything I Need to Know About Being a Manager, I Learned from My Kids